Rice Warner points to exorbitant fees

Superannuation fund members who choose ethical investments need to be careful they are not putting their emotions ahead of value, according to actuarial research house, Rice Warner.

In an analysis of ethical investment options in superannuation, Rice Warner pointed out that statistical evidence suggests that the rates of return between ethical investment options and non-ethical investment options do not vary materially.

However, it suggests that the small amount of assets in ethical options usually means they are more expensive as they lack scale benefits.

Related News:

"We don't expect any material difference in returns from the style of investing though there will be differences in levels of investment competence," the analysis said.

"Nonetheless, people don't appear to pick these options to get better returns. In most cases, it appears that the decision for ethical investment is primarily emotive."

It said this primarily emotive approach had created a risk that superannuants would trade off their emotions against value in products.

"Unfortunately, this risk has been realised, with some products on the market which appeal directly to a member's sense of social obligation, charging exorbitant fees," Rice Warner said.

In doing so, it published a table (below) in which it compared the fees of mainstream funds such as Australian Super and UniSuper and compared them to the fees of relatively recently-established ethical funds some of which were nearly double those of the mainstream.

 




Related Content

SMSF benefit payments rise ahead of super changes

The average benefit payment for self-managed superannuation fund (SMSF) trustees increased significantly from $16,256 to $27,900 during the March quar...more

Long-term underperforming defaults should lose their status

Long-term underperforming default funds should lose their default status, according to the Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees (AIST).AIST...more

APRA/ASIC pilot claims-handling reporting regime

Australia’s two major financial services regulators have begun the pilot phase of their project to improve public reporting of life insurance claims...more

Author

Comments

Add new comment