Universities-based industry fund, UniSuper is calling for a move away from fixed dollar targets with respect to retirement incomes adequacy and towards salary-based targets.
It claims such a move would deliver a more individually relevant measure for superannuation fund members to maintain their pre-retirement standard of living.
The superannuation fund is arguing that the notion of a “comfortable retirement” needs to be redefined with the current one-size-fits-all approach not the most effective way to help Australians achieve optimal retirement outcomes.
It said superannuation funds had traditionally relied on the Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia (ASFA) Retirement Standard to benchmark how members were tracking to retirement income adequacy. However, rather than always using a fixed-dollar target, UniSuper advocates also using salary based targets to deliver a more individually relevant measure to maintain their pre-retirement standard of living.
UniSuper chief executive, Kevin O’Sullivan said: “For the foreseeable future, retirement income will likely remain a mix of the Age Pension and Superannuation savings”.
“While defining the role of superannuation as being to ‘supplement the age pension’ is a positive step forward, taken in isolation, it is quite subjective as it is relative to the standard of living enjoyed by the member prior to retirement,” he said. “It is important for retirees to be able to maintain their standard of living in retirement equivalent to what they enjoyed while working. While that can quite often be done on a lower income, it varies for each individual.”
O’Sullivan said UniSuper believed a more effective approach to understanding how some members were progressing toward their individual retirement goals was salary-based targets that measured an individual’s retirement income as a percentage of their pre-retirement salary – something that is more common globally, and inherent in defined benefit schemes.
“Defined benefit schemes have often been designed to deliver a retirement income stream of around 70 per cent of pre-retirement salary. While replacement rates are a matter of personal choice – an individual may choose to consume more now while still relatively young and healthy – the 70 per cent replacement rate has proven globally to be a realistic and effective level,” he said.
O’Sullivan said that working with global advisory firm Willis Towers Watson, UniSuper had used this global standard recently to develop a deeper understanding of the retirement preparedness of its members.
This Retirement Adequacy Index measures members’ projected retirement income as a percentage of their pre-retirement salary, better assessing how their standard of living in retirement might compare with that enjoyed during their working lives.
Key trends identified among UniSuper members included:
A member of the super fund has approached ASIC to investigate potentially misleading or deceptive representations by UniSuper regarding the holdings of its sustainable portfolios.
The median growth fund delivered 1.9 per cent in March, adding to the “stunning” rally that has seen super funds gain 11 per cent since November.
Vanguard has affirmed its support for the current super performance test, emphasising the importance of keeping the process straightforward.
While some superannuation funds have gone down the route of internalisation, others say they favour ‘smart partnering’ with external managers for diversification appeal.
Add new comment