POWERED BY MOMENTUM MEDIA
ANU study on SG ‘a fantasy’: ISA
Industry Super Australia (ISA) has criticised an Australian National University (ANU) study on the superannuation guarantee (SG).
The study questioned whether it was necessary to lift the SG to 12% from 9.5% as lower-income earners would have less money during their working lives, and would extend overly generous tax breaks to the wealthy.
ISA said the researchers had created a “fantasy world where every Australian is a single man who is in the workforce for more than 40 straight years”.
It also said the fantasy man never ran a business, got injured or had illness that forced him out of work, made redundant or had a study break.
“Women do not exist and no parent takes time out of work to raise children,” ISA said.
“Australia’s 3.9 million casual or part-time workers would be shocked to learn that the ANU researchers have modelled them out of existence. There is no savings other than super – no family homes, investment properties, shares or bonds.”
ISA said the model did not include unpaid super and said the research’s scope of analysis was so limited that “no meaningful conclusions could be drawn from it. Let alone the dangerous recommendations it makes which would lead to millions of Australians flooding onto the pension, leaving everyone to pay in the long run”.
ISA chief executive, Bernie Dean, said the results had no benchmarks to reality, were flawed and misleading.
“In this fantasy world women and children don’t exist and it assumes all men work continuously for more than 40 years and have no assets outside of super,” he said.
“It draws dangerous conclusions - if implemented millions of Australians would be left struggling to make ends meet on the pension, or forced to work until they drop.”
ISA said the only way Australians would have dignity, choice, and control in retirement was to increase the SG to 12%.
Other issues ISA found with the research were:
- Everything is indexed by the same percentage;
- With no women or children in the world, there is no need for family tax benefit with a means test which counteracts different wage movements;
- There is no test of whether any assumptions hold in history or that the balances produced by the model benchmark to reality; and
- They optimise for the replacement rate of the first five years of retirement to the five years of working life when they have their lowest wage. This is not reflective of what actually happens and generates biased results.
Recommended for you
The equities investor has launched a new long-short fund seeded by UniSuper, targeting alpha from ASX 300 equities using AI insights.
The fund has strengthened efforts to boost gender diversity, targeting 40:40:20 balance across its investment teams by 2030.
The lower outlook for inflation has set the stage for another two rate cuts over the first half of 2026, according to Westpac.
With private asset valuations emerging as a key concern for both regulators and the broader market, Apollo Global Management has called on the corporate regulator to issue clear principles on valuation practices, including guidance on the disclosures it expects from market participants.
TOP PERFORMING FUNDS
ACS FIXED INT - AUSTRALIA/GLOBAL BOND
Fund name
3y(%)pa
1
DomaCom DFS Mortgage
92.15 3 y p.a(%)
2
Global X 21Shares Bitcoin ETF
53.24 3 y p.a(%)
3
Global X GlobalX FANG+ ETF
43.15 3 y p.a(%)
4
DomaCom Shoreline North Coogee
36.26 3 y p.a(%)
5
GAM LSA Private Shares AU I
35.87 3 y p.a(%)
